Carroll College vs. UM Western

Carroll College vs. The University of Montana Western comparison

	Carroll College	The University of Montana Western	College 3	College 4
	Remove	Remove	+Add	+Add
Overview	Carroll College	UM Western
Location	Helena, MT	Dillon, MT
Setting	Remote Town	Remote Town
Enrollment	1,168	1,424
Type	Private 4 Year	Public 4 Year
National Ranking	#447	#931
Religious Affiliation	Roman Catholic	-	-	-
Status	Non-profit	Non-profit
Website	carroll.edu	umwestern.edu
Team Colors

Costs	Carroll College	UM Western
Tuition (In State)	$37,828	$4,658
Tuition (Out of State)	$37,828	$16,406
Room & Board	$11,182	$8,588
Avg Net Price	$23,916	$11,584
Avg Grant Aid	$28,266	$8,117
% Receiving Grant Aid	100%	99%

Admission	Carroll College	UM Western
Admission Chances	Calculate	Calculate
Applied	1,519	1,476
Admitted	1,186	536
Acceptance Rate	78.1%	36.3%Open
Enrolled %	25%	50.6%Open
Avg High School GPA	3.64	3.2
Typical High School Grades	B+	B
Admissions Standards	Average	Extremely Easy
Applicant Competition		High
ACT Range	13/29	16/21
SAT Range	1080/1200	890/1120
Submit Test Scores	Not required for admission, but considered if submitted (Test Optional)	Not considered for admission, even if submitted (Test Blind)
Application Deadline	Feb 28, 2025

Academics	Carroll College	UM Western
Student to Faculty Ratio	12:1	15:1
Popular Majors	Business (15%) Health Professions (14%) Biology (11%) Education (9%) Psychology (7%)	Education (47%) Business (25%) Liberal Arts and Humanities (17%) Agriculture (6%) General Studies (4%)
Outcomes	Carroll College	UM Western
Graduation Rate	59%	31%
Median Earnings (After 10 years)	$47,500	$34,100
Making Student Loan Payments	81%	61%
Median Student Loan Debt	$27,000	$20,929
Median Loan Payment	$279	$216

Diversity	Carroll College	UM Western
% Men	39%	32%
% Women	61%	68%
Racial Diversity	Very Low	Very Low
HBCU	No	No
% White	80%	88%
% Black	1%	1%
% Hispanic	5%	3%
% Native American	1%	3%
% Pacific Islander	0%	0%
% Two or More Races	2%	2%
% International	1%	0%
% Unknown Race	7%	2%

Students	Carroll College	UM Western
% In-State	39%	57%
% Out-of-State	60%	43%
Campus	Carroll College	UM Western
Campus Housing	Yes	Yes
Freshman Dorm Required	No	No
Meal Plan	Yes	Yes
Weekend/Evening Classes	No	Yes
Daycare Facility	No	Yes
Learn More	Details	Details

Comparable Facts

• The University of Montana Western is larger than than Carroll College based on total student enrollment (1,424 students vs. 1,168 students)

Carroll College vs. UM Western Cost Comparison

Which college is more expensive, Carroll College or UM Western?

• Carroll College is 712.1% more expensive to attend than UM Western for in-state tuition ($37,828.00 vs. $4,658.00)
• Out of state tuition is 130.6% higher at Carroll College than The University of Montana Western ($37,828.00 vs. $16,406.00)
• The typical actual cost that students pay to attend (average net price) is less at The University of Montana Western than Carroll College ($11,584 vs. $23,916)
• Living costs (room and board or off-campus housing budget) at The University of Montana Western are 30.2% lower than costs at Carroll College ($8,588 vs. $11,182)
• More students receive financial grant aid at Carroll College than The University of Montana Western (100% vs. 99%)
• The average total grant financial aid received by Carroll College students is 248.2% larger than aid received The University of Montana Western ($28,266 vs. $8,117)

Carroll College vs. UM Western Admissions Difficulty Comparison

Which college is harder to get into, Carroll College or UM Western? Average SAT and ACT scores plus acceptance rates offer good insight into the difficulty of admission between UM Western or Carroll College .

• Accepted freshman Carroll College students have a 0.44 point higher average high school GPA (3.64) than students at UM Western (3.2)
• Carroll College has a higher acceptance rate (78.1%) than UM Western (36.3%)

Carroll College vs. UM Western Graduation Outcomes Comparison

Which is better, Carroll College or UM Western? Graduation rate, salary and amount of student loan debt are indicators of a college which offers better outcomes for its graduates. Compare the following outcomes facts between UM Western and Carroll College.

• The graduation rate at Carroll College is higher than The University of Montana Western (59% vs. 31%)
• Graduates from Carroll College earn on average $13,400 more per year than UM Western graduates after ten years. ($47,500 vs. $34,100)
• The University of Montana Western students graduate with a $6,071 lower median federal student loan debt than Carroll College graduates. ($20,929 vs. $27,000)
• UM Western graduates are paying $63 less per month on federal student loans than Carroll College graduates. ($216 vs. $279)
• More Carroll College graduates are actively paying back their federal student loan debt than former UM Western students, three years after graduation. (81% vs. 61%)

Sources: U.S. Department of Education https://nces.ed.gov IPEDS and College Scorecard https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/